Defendants in clinical negligence cases often challenge the claims we put forward on behalf of our clients, and in particular, assert that the injury has had a more minimal effect than we have alleged. They can do this on the basis of their medical evidence (from the expert doctors they have instructed to assist them with the case) but also by surveillance.
A Defendant is entitled to investigate whether what a Claimant says about of the effect of their injuries upon their lifestyle is genuine. Whilst they are entitled to do this in any case, in practice, they mainly tend to do it only when a person is severely disabled and their day to day activities are limited as a result.
In our experience there are 2 main ways in which they do this:
- Looking at a person’s social media presence, i.e. Facebook, Instagram, Twitter etc. A Defendant can ask a Judge to order a Claimant to provide copies of their posts, photographs etc. for them to consider.
- If we claim that a person is housebound, has problems walking, getting in and out of cars or needs help with shopping or doing things outside of the home, the Defendant may check to see if this is genuine. This could involve filming that person, for example, driving, attending the supermarket or at public events to see if the injuries and limitations are consistent what we have claimed.
The benefit to a Defendant if they can show a Claimant is not as badly affected as alleged is twofold. Firstly, it will help them prove that the level of damages the Claimant is due is less. Secondly, and more importantly, the Court has power to dismiss the entirety of a claim if it is satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the Claimant has been “fundamentally dishonest” in relation to any aspect of the claim.
This is nothing to worry about and certainly not a reason to avoid looking into bringing a medical negligence claim if you think you may have received substandard treatment. The vast majority of Claimants are honest and accurately report their symptoms and the effect any injury has had on them. However, it is something to bear in mind if you are bringing a claim, especially if you are thinking of trying things you previously thought impossible. In this situation, we would ask that you keep us informed so we can make sure that the Defendant and our experts are aware of it. If you find these changes last for just a short period of time, it will prevent a situation where the Defendant believes they have evidence that you are more able than we have previously stated.
If you would like to discuss this further or think you may have a claim for medical negligence and would like some advice from one of our solicitors, please contact us on 01642 231110.
Kathryn Watson – April 2018